Fatherhood Poll. Glee Related.
Nov. 27th, 2009 01:39 pmSo. The family is watching the TV show Glee. As part of the show, one of the female characters (Quinn) is impregnated by the school lothario (Puck), but her regular boyfriend (Finn) thinks the child is his and she is allowing that misconception. Puck knows the kid is his and everything goes round and round in humorous fashion.
In the most recent episode, Quinn actually considers that Puck might be a better father for her child than Finn. Ultimately she decides on Finn as the best father of her baby. My wife and I had a discussion about this and thought it would make a good Livejournal discussion.
Finn is the all American stereotypical quarterback. He's none to bright and shows an amazing lack of initiative. One gets the impression he is pretty good at doing what is expected of him but you get the impression if he were left in a field he'd just slowly starve to death. He's very nice and caring. He is surprisingly progressive. (He objected to the football players tormenting the oddball characters and has been surprisingly tolerant of the Gay Character although that could also be a sign of his cluelessness)
Puck is a criminal. He sells pot. He lies and steals. He sleeps around with not only other high school girls, but their mothers. However he is very resourceful. He owns his own legitimate business in addition to his drug dealing. He obviously cares a great deal about the baby and is willing to do 'whatever it takes' to provide for the baby.
So here is the thing. Is being a nice guy better than being a provider? I think both Finn and Puck will love the child. I don't think Puck necessarily loves Quinn. But I also don't think Finn will be a very good provider for the child.
As part of the hypothetical, Quinn cannot give the child away. Who does she spend her life with?
In the most recent episode, Quinn actually considers that Puck might be a better father for her child than Finn. Ultimately she decides on Finn as the best father of her baby. My wife and I had a discussion about this and thought it would make a good Livejournal discussion.
Finn is the all American stereotypical quarterback. He's none to bright and shows an amazing lack of initiative. One gets the impression he is pretty good at doing what is expected of him but you get the impression if he were left in a field he'd just slowly starve to death. He's very nice and caring. He is surprisingly progressive. (He objected to the football players tormenting the oddball characters and has been surprisingly tolerant of the Gay Character although that could also be a sign of his cluelessness)
Puck is a criminal. He sells pot. He lies and steals. He sleeps around with not only other high school girls, but their mothers. However he is very resourceful. He owns his own legitimate business in addition to his drug dealing. He obviously cares a great deal about the baby and is willing to do 'whatever it takes' to provide for the baby.
So here is the thing. Is being a nice guy better than being a provider? I think both Finn and Puck will love the child. I don't think Puck necessarily loves Quinn. But I also don't think Finn will be a very good provider for the child.
As part of the hypothetical, Quinn cannot give the child away. Who does she spend her life with?